Girls want to be Zooey Deschanel, and guys want to do her. If there’s another reason for She & Him’s popularity, I haven’t been able to figure it out, and their new album just reinforces that — it’s the kind of record that deserves to be titled Volume Two. About the only thing that stands out is their cover of NRBQ’s “Ridin’ in My Car,” and that’s only because it’s such an inappropriate choice; Deschanel isn’t a bad singer, per se, but her delivery is all about cool detachment (and/or hipster-flavored boredom), neither of which have anything to do with the Q.

Bruce Willis never would have had a record deal if he hadn’t been Bruce Willis, and no matter how cute she is, or how capably she carries these very, very slight songs, I think the same is true of Zooey Deschanel. Except where Willis was at least using his smirk to refract some of his celebrity, Blues Brothers style, on performers like Johnny Winter and Merry Clayton, Deschanel is just doing the same thing you can hear in any random L.A. nightclub on most weeknights.

Volume Two doesn’t come out until next week, but you can already stream the whole thing for free, thanks to NPR.

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]
  • That's a great way to describe her voice. I've always felt like I've been one of the few people who not only didn't like that album, but deleted it from my iTunes. It wasn't so much that I hated it, I just knew I'd never have a desire to listen to it again. I think she's utterly charming, I loved her in 500 Days of Summer and Elf, and I don't think she has a bad voice either — she just does nothing for me in the music department.

  • Yeah, exactly. I know people who think they're incredible, but c'mon.